Mayonnaise Recipe, a Homemade Artform

Getting a feel for making homemade mayonnaise has been an interesting experience. A bit frustrating at first, but fun once perfected. Now the saying, “harder than not breaking mayonnaise,” has become somewhat of a thing in our home.

Breaking Mayonnaise

So, first off, making mayonnaise is emulsification cooking. Therefore, as you’re mixing the oil into the egg yolks and other ingredients, you have to do so slowly and carefully. This is so that the mixture can maintain the consistency of mayonnaise. Breaking mayonnaise is when the oil is added too quickly/not mixed-in thoroughly. This allows the oil to separate from the rest of the mixture and become a liquid mess. There are ways to fix such a mess back into mayonnaise, but I must admit that I have never been able to successfully do so. I simply prefer to steadily get it right the first time.

Picture of Rimakej slowly pouring about a teaspoons worth of canola oil from a glass liquid measuring cup into a glass mixing bowl with the beginning mixture of mayonnaise in it. Her other hand is holding a green silicone hand whisk she used to mix the mayonnaise.
Adding oil a little at a time into my mayonnaise mixture.

Why Not Use a Blender?

Not many people realize the feel work that goes into the emulsification process of making mayonnaise. I know a lot of recipe books instruct to use a blender, but that wasn’t for me. Tried it once and never again. I’ve always been one to have a natural knack for mixing things. It’s an artform, so why deny myself the ease of using my own creative instincts? Then of course, there is always the added plus of reducing ones carbon footprint by choosing hand-power over electricity.

Blurred action picture of Rimakej's left hand vigorously mixing the mayonnaise with a green silicone hand whisk.
Hand Power Whisking!

Why Homemade?

My first time making mayonnaise was rooted in the beginnings of our homesteading years. This was when we were trying to save money and reduce our waste, since we had no trash service and now a large mortgage to pay monthly. Not to mention trying to avoid the pains of searching for the nonexistent organic mayonnaise at our local grocery store.

We also had just started collecting eggs from our Silkie hens and wanted to be able to solely consume egg products from them. This was to be 100% sure that the animals providing us these eggs had healthy and happy lives. This was also before we had discovered Cristophe’s soy intolerance including his sensitivity to consuming eggs from chickens that were fed soy. At that time, we were mixing our own chicken feed from organic whole grains and lentils, which did not include soy. Now that we are not able to share our current home with chickens, we have luckily found a brand that sells humane, pasture raised, organic, local, and soy-free eggs. Next best thing for now, but chickens are a definite for our future homestead!

Notes on Egg Storage

Chickens lay eggs with a natural protective antibacterial coating covering the outer shell. This is why most of the egg-eating world, excluding Americans, do not need to refrigerate their eggs. The reason why Americans have been conditioned to do so, is because big agriculture uses factory farming processes that strip that natural protective coating from their eggs before they are sold. This means that their eggs are very susceptible to bacterial growth and becoming unsafe to consume sooner, especially if stored at room temperature. Therefore, they have made refrigeration a necessity for their products, and convinced the general population that all eggs need to be stored cold.

I bring this information up because temperature affects emulsification. So, for those of you not in America, or who collect your own eggs from your own healthy chickens, emulsify away! As for those of you who still buy washed conventional eggs that require refrigeration, I am sorry to tell you that you’ll have to wait the extra time for those eggs to come to room temperature first.

Picture of organic cane sugar, organic ground mustard seed, organic ground cayenne pepper, organic canola oil, and organic apple cider vinegar stored separately in various containers lined up in a row with organic whole peppercorns in a grinder behind two organic brown eggs and a small organic lemon.
All of my mayonnaise ingredients, except for the sea salt. Sorry, I forgot it when taking this picture, but I promise I did put it in the mayonnaise!

Mayonnaise Recipe


(Note: All organic and freshly ground/freshly juiced ingredients makes a huge difference in increased flavor and nutrition!)

Picture of a spice container labeled, "Organic Mustard Seed," next to a black stone mortar and pestle and another spice container holding ground organic mustard seed.
Freshly hand ground organic mustard seed for optimum flavor!
  • 2 egg yolks
  • 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
  • 1/2 teaspoon sea/mineral salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon cane sugar
  • 1/8 teaspoon ground peppercorn
  • 1/8 teaspoon ground cayenne pepper
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground mustard seed
  • 1 cup canola oil
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  1. Combine the (room temperature) egg yolks, vinegar, salt, sugar, peppers, and mustard into a small mixing bowl.
  2. Mix together using a hand whisk until well blended.
  3. Add one teaspoon of oil and beat vigorously into mixture until well blended.
  4. Repeat step three. You can increase the amount of oil added gradually during this process, but I prefer to maintain the addition of a little at a time in order to not risk breaking the mayonnaise. This is the part that requires gaining a feel for the mixing. You will notice the texture thickening and lightening in color. Stop once you have added half of your cup of oil.
  5. Next alternate between adding a few drops of lemon juice and more of the oil, while continuing to mix vigorously after each addition. Do this until all of the lemon juice and oil have been mixed in.
  6. Now you have mayonnaise! Store it in a covered container in the refrigerator for a cooler and firmer consistency.
Close-up picture of a glass mixing bowl containing homemade organic mayonnaise with a green silicone whisk above it slowly dripping the fresh creamy mayonnaise back into the bowl.
Final product of delicious homemade mayonnaise!

Enjoy using your homemade mayonnaise in yummy dishes such as our chickweed potato salad pictured below!

Picture of a small glass container holding homemade potato salad made of chucks of boiled organic Yukon gold potatoes, diced organic yellow onion, homemade organic mayonnaise, organic mustard, and wild foraged chickweed.
Homemade potato salad made of chucks of boiled organic Yukon gold potatoes, diced organic yellow onion, homemade organic mayonnaise, organic mustard, and wild foraged chickweed.

Did you find this post helpful? Follow us on Facebook/Instagram, for more information and to never miss a post!

6 Replies to “Mayonnaise Recipe, a Homemade Artform”

  1. 4 stars
    My relatives always say that I am wasting my time here at net,
    but I know I am getting know-how every day by reading thes pleasant articles or reviews.

  2. 1 star
    Pretty great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say
    that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    After all I will be subscribing on your feed and I am hoping you write once more
    very soon!

    1. Thank you for reading! We appreciate your feedback. Please do sign up on our emailing list, or follow us on our Facebook and/or Instagram pages, to be notified as soon as we publish another blog!

  3. 2 stars
    It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button!
    I’d definitely donate to this fantastic blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google
    account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this site with my Facebook
    group. Chat soon!

    1. We actually do have a donate button! It is available on the bottom righthand corner of every page on our website. We appreciate your support! And, thank you very much for helping us to spread the love and learning by sharing our site. We look forward to your return!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *